Home » Business »Copyright »Legal » Currently Reading:

I Copied A David Muench Picture and it Never Sold!

April 19, 2011 Business, Copyright, Legal 5 Comments

Written by: Charlie Borland

Yes, I confess, I did it. This was back when I was a student at Brooks Institute of Photography in the 1970s. In my very first class, the instructor had us study many of the well-known photographers throughout the history of the medium, including David Muench. I quickly became a David Muench fan, and, in fact, he has been my hero since those early days. He is a ground breaker, capturing countless never-before-seen locations in new and innovative ways as many of the early landscape photographers did.

So many times I wished I had entered the business when David Muench had. It must have been easier. If you documented the landscape where nobody spent much time, then every image would be a new, never-before-seen image. There were fewer photographers then and less competition.

In reality, I’m sure it was not that easy. Most likely, many of the battles would have been the same as they are today: working hard to build name recognition; finding clients; creating unique imagery; and building a successful business.

As a student at Brooks, I made my first trip to Death Valley with another student after I had seen a David Muench image of Badwater. As a new student of photography, I wanted to emulate my hero. My buddy and I arrived at Badwater before the sunrise and I quickly started trying to figure out where David had photographed his iconic image. It didn’t take long to locate the rock out there in the water. As I moved my 4 x 5 left and right trying to get close to the same composition as David’s picture, my buddy hollered, “Does it have to be exactly the same?” His comment went in one ear and out the other. Of course it had to be exactly the same or as close as I could get. I wanted my work to be as good as that of David Muench, and the best way to do that, I thought at the time, was to shoot like him. Of course, only the composition was close. You can never recreate the lighting of an image taken at a different time.

Badwater, Death Valley

I placed my image of Badwater in my growing stock photo files. Over the years, I sent it out on countless submissions to photo editors hoping I could license it, thus validating that I was as good as David Muench. It never sold. Why? I don’t know and often wondered. In my opinion, it is a good photo. Maybe the markets where I was sending my images had already seen David’s image, published it, and had no use for my version. Maybe I had bad karma from emulating another photographer’s picture.

It is common for art and photography students to emulate the work of others. It’s part of the learning process. We study their use of light and how it shapes the land, as well as how  they compose the grand scenes before them.  A few years after college, however, I learned that attempting to duplicate the work of other photographers may be good for learning but less so for business. (Still later, I learned that it is also illegal.)

If you look at today’s markets and how many more working photographers there are now than there were in the 1970s, you cannot help but wonder how much image emulation takes place. I’ve heard other photographers and workshop students discuss whether they’ve been to a certain location and “got the shot.” It’s that urge to photograph places that we see published and have never visited that drives much of our decision-making on where and what to shoot. It’s not so much our desire to engage in smart business decisions or what we should shoot as it is to have the experience of shooting these places where “everybody shoots.”

Many photographers have all the usual locations covered: Delicate Arch, Half Dome, Toroweap, Mount Rushmore, and countless more. The need to get the shots we see published is often mistaken as a good business practice. But is it really?

The hike to Delicate Arch will often result in photographers lined up shoulder-to-shoulder for the same shot. Granted, not all of them are there to take photos that they hope to market and license. But some are, and that means competition with the same shot taken on the same day.

In practice, there are only so many calendar publishers. The photo buyers for these companies see many new and striking compositions, but they also see many of the same locations shot in the same old way. The perception of the stock photo industry is changing, and complaints are growing among photo buyers that there is too much of the same imagery and it is difficult to find fresh material.

As the market gets more and more crowded, photographers hoping to prosper (or even simply survive) will have no choice but to innovate rather than imitate. We do not have the option of redesigning the landscape with new rivers, mountains and oceans like some computer game. Instead, we have what we have: national parks, wilderness and natural areas, coastlines and wildlife, and they have all been photographed before we came on the scene. The challenge to today’s nature photographers is to look at these areas in a new way.

Those photographers doing something innovative rise above the crowd. A photo editor’s job is not only to obtain needed photos, but to find and nurture promising talent. We see this all the time in the major publications dedicated to photography.  They showcase the work of photographers who do it differently.

Those creative thinkers who have a different take are the ones grabbing the image sales and assignments. No matter how long you’ve been in the business, the need to innovate, experiment and do things differently should be a high priority.

I see pictures published of places I have never been and I certainly wish to go there myself. Today, if the locations fit my business plan I go, but I don’t try to emulate pictures I have seen published. The markets are too small these days. I want my work to stand out from the crowd. At the same time, I can continue to honor the work of David Muench by simply looking at his pictures.

If you have any thoughts please leave a comment.

Related Posts: Copying Other Photographers Images; Good, Bad, Legal?

Books by David Muench:

This post originally appeared in the Summer 2010 issue of Currents, the journal of the North American Nature Photographers Association. If you are not a member, consider joining the best organization for nature photographer advocacy and education. www.nanpa.org

Be Sociable, Share!

Currently there are "5 comments" on this Article:

  1. Todd Kaplan says:

    I too emulated David Muench’s work back in the early 90’s. His images were and still are compeling. A geography professor of mine (who was an accomplished photographer as well) showed me a book, it’s title, Timberline Ancients by David Muench.. I was inthralled by the striking images of the Brisltecone pine tree, the oldest living thing on planet earth. California’s White Mountains harbor the oldest and most photogenic of these trees and dramatic views of the Sierra Nevada and Great Basin add to it’s allure. Since that time I’ve been back to this remarkable place several times, still in awe of their enduring beauty. When my family and friends see a photogenic tree they say. It’s a Muenchie tree or a Todd tree. (Muenchie sounds better though) and I will always remember that book and the people who have enlightened me.

    Thanks David, Charlie and Stan for enlightening me about those special places we love to go and photograph.

  2. Kelly Hoover says:

    I was trying to google and see if I could find Davids picture of his daughter Zandria in front of a large redwood tree. I think Marc is in this one too. Anyway, stumbled upon this information. I found it to be very interesting and informative. I grew up in Santa Barbara and knew the Muench clan quite well during the 70’s. Went on a few hikes, got to go over a few of the negatives at the house. All in alll I have very fond memories of that period in my life and of the Muenchs. David was always just a big kid, it was super cool to hang at their house! He is and always will be my favorite nature photographer. As far as seeing people try and copy Davids style. I’ve seen many try and not even come close. He has that ability to grab your attention and entrance you. You can almost always tell if a photo is Davids or not. There definitely is a signature “feel” to his stuff.


  3. I feel that it’s ok to get the “classic” image, at least for yourself, so you have it. It may not be something that is going to sell, because like Charlie said the competition is extreme and the market is flooded with similar image. However I think for some photographers they have that classic image in their mind and it’s only after they capture their own version can they go beyond the generic and start to express their own unique creative vision.

  4. […] Posts: I Copied A David Muench Picture and it Never Sold!, Watermarks Are Valid Copyright Information: Says the […]

  5. […] unique style is echoed by many of today’s landscape photographers. I have written about David here and am honored to be interviewing him for a video series featured here on Pro Nature: The David […]

Comment on this Article:


"Infinity View" -Montana De Oro SP

visit ebook store




Subscribe by email:


Permission to pin, re-pin, or post images on Pinterest, Instagram (or any site) taken from this site is expressly forbidden without written permission from the copyright holder of the image. If you do not have that permission, do not pin, re-pin, or post images from this site on Pinterest, Instagram, or any other site. If you do re-pin or re-post any image from this site, you assume all liability in how any image re-posted or re-pinned by you, is used, infringed, or results in copyright violations. If we find you re-posted, re-pinned, or copied an image we will come calling. Why? Unauthorized and illegal use that is clearly defined under copyright infringement laws has occurred with images lifted off this site. Thank you!
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Our Mission
  • The ProNature eBook Store
  • The David Muench Interview Series
  • 2014
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010